The Significance of Mosque of Cristo de la Luz (Mosque of Bab Mardum).
The Significance Of The Historical Cubed Mosque of Bab Mardum
(Now referred to as Mosque of Cristo De La Luz)
Figure 1
Patron: Musa ibn Alí
Title: Mosque of Bab Mardum
Date: 999 during the Umayyad dynasty
Size/ Dimensions: 8m x 8m
Graphic Origin: Umayyad dynasty
Located in Calle Cristo de la Luz, 22, 45002 Toledo, Spain. The Mosque of Bab Mardum is a Mosque and was originally built in December 999 during the Umayyad dynasty. The patron of this magnificent structure is Ahmad Ibn Hadidi. Ultimately, the mosque was converted into a church in 1085, the year of the Christian conquest of Toledo. It was built by Ahmad ibn Hadidi, a member of a prestigious Toledo family whose name is included in the foundation inscription on the top of the main façade in reward of helping fund the building process. In return, he wanted credit therefore his name was engraved into the building. It is one of the ten that existed in the city during the Moorish period. The building was then known as Mezquita Bab-al-Mardum, it initially got its name from the city door Bab al-Mardum and is located close to the Puerta del Sol, in a space of the city once called Medina where financially stable Muslims used to live. One can say that this structure was built here because since it holds wealthy prehistoric prestige in its location, it could have been believed that building a magnificent structure of such may get the best recognition of its deserved value since it is located in a very luxurious location where wealthy people used to live. Upon building this structure, the patron must think to himself where would be the best location for this structure. One would rather not want to build a structure in the middle of nowhere, where there is no sentimental value. On the other hand, one can understand and acknowledge why it was that this historical building was crafted in such a location in Toledo, Spain for that same reason. Due to the fact that this location was known to be wealthy, and also there is a small garden and a water fountain next to the mosque which means, many people can go visit the beautiful garden and water fountain which will then lead them next to the significant mosque in which it will now catch more civilians attention. This mosque needed to be perfectly placed and balanced within where it wanted to be constructed and there couldn’t have been a better location.
Constructed in 999 in Toledo, this structure is extraordinary due to the fact that it is in a much similar state as it was at the point at which it was originally assembled. The structure is a little square almost like a cube-like dice and estimates approximately 8 m × 8m. Four columns capped with Visigothic capitals divide the interior into nine compartments. Covering each of these columns is a vault that has a distinctive design that is unique to itself. The structure is filled with horseshoe arches going all around it from the outside view. It is a distinctive brownish color that can be seen throughout the outside entrance near the gate and even inside. The inside is a light beige brown colorway which also holds horseshoes arches through the ceiling. The structure from the inside almost looks like a marble color, it is made out of stone and gives off Roman Catholic Church vibes as a mini version to the historic catholic church by the way it is designed with arches in the ceiling and pillars within the inside. “The building is constructed of brick and small stones. These techniques are a reflection of both the local building tradition as well as the influence from the caliphate in Córdoba. The influence of the caliphate can be seen in the brickwork on the facade of the building which resembles those seen at the Cathedral–Mosque of Córdoba. Both the Mosque of Cristo de la Luz with Cathedral–Mosque of Córdoba are the oldest examples of the Islamic culture in Spain” (Madain Project, 1).
Figure 2
Patron: Musa ibn Alí
Title: Mosque of Bab Mardum
Date: 999 during the Umayyad dynasty
Size/ Dimensions: 8m x 8m
Graphic Origin: Umayyad dynasty
For instance, as one can see in figure 2, there are nine divided segments when standing inside the structure and looking upwards towards the ceiling with each having its own design and implying a different meaning. It is crucial to understand how the focal vault is higher than different ones the reasoning behind its structure is because the building was specifically structured in a way that it included particular fundamental beliefs of the Islamic world idea in its way of being portrayed through the way it was built with arches. The bars initially don't cross in the middle, a thought that is seen in numerous Muslim representations. A portion of the structure is more rectilinear while others embrace the bent types of the vault all the more conspicuously. Inside the building, everything is a piece of their way of life and custom to their own way. “The segments and the assets both had been taken from past structures and are accordingly known as spolia which is the reproduction of an ancient and prevalent tradition in which stone that has been quarried, removed, and used in a constructed structure taken away to be used elsewhere is repurposed building stone for new buildings, or decorative sculpture reused in new monuments”( Franco,1). “The structure is built of blocks and little stones which are methods that give an impression of both the neighborhood building custom just as the impact from the caliphate in Córdoba”(Rabah,9). The impact of the caliphate can be found in the brickwork on the exterior of the structure which takes after those seen at the Church building Mosque of Córdoba. Both the Mosque of Cristo de la Luz and the Basilica Mosque of Córdoba is the most established instances of the Islamic culture in Spain by far. They both hold the significance of the arches although, the building of Cordoba has lines and different coloring, they are both splendidly historic and hold prestigious value due to pre-historic pasts. “A large percentage of the population converted in Islam, demanding the construction of mosques throughout Al- Andalus. Following the example of the typological characteristics set by the great mosque of Cordoba… large new mosques were built in Toledo… However, and unfortunately, when the Cristian kingdoms recovered the cities most of the mosques were replaced by Cristian cathedrals”(Lapunzina, 127).
Eventually, King Alfonso VIII who was known as the Noble or the one of Las Navas was King of Castile and King of Toledo from 1158 to 1214 and was best known for his role in the Reconquista and the Almohad Caliphate's demise decided to give the building to the Order of the Hospital of the Holy Cross in 1182. Ater, Christian elements were then added to it after such as the semi-circle dome at the top of the altar and murals of Christian figures, one of which is located in the east end of the church of Christ. The building was also influenced by other mosques such as the Great Mosque of Cordoba from the blind arches and the vaults which are the arched roof. This is why they look comparable in that sense despite being different colored and Cordoba having lines within the arches. Also, the Arabic inscription in Kufic on the building states that Musa Ibn Ali built it. Ahmad ibn Hadidi had this mosque constructed using his own money requesting a reward in return for it from Allah. It was completed with the aid of Allah under the direction of Musa ibn Alí, architect and Sa'ada, and concluded in Muharram in 390.
In addition, during the construction, it is said to be believed that a shaft of light guided the king to a figurine of the crucified Christ that had been hidden for centuries. When discovered people were in shock of such coincidence that had taken place, people were in disbelief and thought it could have been a message from christ himself that they were at the right place at the right time or that he was converting a message that could have not been understood too clearly. The shield was left there with the inscription, over the years it was originally renamed Mezquita Bab-al-Mardum which comes from the city gate with the same name.
Despite its small size, it is very well preserved making it the only Moorish mosque in the city that didn't have any huge changes to it despite the semi-circle dome at the top of the altar and murals of Christian figures, however, as mentioned earlier is located in the east end of the church. It has Moorish and early Gothic elements such as the Kufic script and the heads of the columns. There are also ribs in the domes in each section that relate to early Gothic architecture. The building has a rectangular floor design, and the façade is ornamented with a sequence of arches reminiscent of Cordoba's Great Mosque. Referring back to figure 2, the building is a lighter brown stone-colored from the outside and holds a primary beige with white throughout the inside. The texture of the building can be described as smooth and rough in some sections due to the falling pieces of stone over time. It consists of horseshoe arches that support nine vaults on the inside, with various designs in different parts of the center. When it was consecrated for Christian worship, the transept was added, along with a Mudéjar-style apse with hidden arches.
Figure 3
In figure 3 one can see the main place where the body and blood of Christ are given in my local church which is St Mathias and is located in Huntington Park, CA. I went out to my city in hope of finding things that I can connect to things that we have learned in the course or in a way the mosque of Bab Mardum. As I was not able to get information about when this church was built and by who, one can see in the figure, towards the background, how the walls have similar horseshoe arches throughout the hallway along with pillars holding them up. This relates to the structure of the Mosque of Bab Mardum which we can see both share the Islamic figures of arches along with the pillars holding those arches up. Inside my local church, these arches and the whole building are made up of stone and marble as one can see in the sitting area. It is light smooth, calm, beige with a white and brown colorway that goes all around the church giving it a light and nice attractive touch. The marble is smooth while the stone arches and buildings are made out of are rough. If one were to slide their hands through the marble nothing will happen to your hand, however, if one were to slide your hand through the stone of the building and arches it may potentially leave your hand feeling rough and may cause minor cuts.
Figure 4
In addition, similarly to figure 3, as one can see in figure 4, surrounding the halls of the church are arched along with a huge arch down the main middle section where the priest gives mass. This relates to figure 3 along with the Mosque of Bab Mardum, and even the great Mosque of Cordoba. One can even say that this figure can relate more to the walking path of the Mosque of Cordoba if there was more walking space. This church can be pictured as white surrounding the church inside and out. This church is mainly made up of smooth shiny wood pieces along with the benches around the church to make the color white pop out more and be more attractive. These walls are made out of wood unlike the ones in figure 3 that are made up of stone.
In conclusion, overall the Mosque of Bab Mardum is significant to its extent because it holds sentimental power of Islamic pasts, designs, architecture, the meaning of what was going on during the dynasty, and there were only 10 ever built. What attracted my group to this source is how tiny this structure is. When one thinks about Islamic structures and historical architecture, one may think about these huge buildings with domes and lots of spread-out space with land and buildings surrounding them. However, when we stumbled upon the Mosque of Bab Mardum, we were surprised at how tiny it was compared to other structures that we have covered in class which is why we were attracted to do this significant building. We came into this assignment ignorant about this structure and what it meant to the Islamic world, however, we now leave well educated and with the confidence to be able to explain to someone else now who has never heard of this Mosque before.
By,
Christopher Estrada & Noel Baltazar, group 2, word count: 2155.
https://madainproject.com/mosque_of_cristo_de_la_luz
Anne D’Alleva, “The Fundamentals of Interpretation: Formal and Contextual Analysis” from her book Look! The Fundamentals of Art History.
TOLEDO, CASTILLA-LA. "MOSQUE OF BĀB-AL-MARDŪM, TOLEDO, CASTILLA-LA MANCHA." Architecture of Spain (2005): 127.
Saoud, Rabah. "Architecture in Muslim Spain and North Africa (756-1500AD)."
Hutcheson, Gregory S. "Contesting the Mezquita del Cristo de la Luz." La corónica: A Journal of Medieval Hispanic Languages, Literatures, and Cultures 43.1 (2014): 201-229.
http://islamicart.museumwnf.org/database_item.php?id=monument;ISL;es;Mon01;3;en
You guys had great analyzes of “The Mosque of Bab Mardum”, we really like how this was organized! It was great how you talked about the sentimental of the power of Islamic pasts, designs, architecture. Great use through quotes and images. Overall, this essay was well-written and highly organized, therefore easy to read. Good job!-Jenyfer & Matthew
ReplyDeleteYour analysis of the Mosque was very in-depth and detailed. The significance of the Mosque in Toledo and Spain is something that should not be downplayed, as Spain's Islamic past is sentimentalized to an extent, as you say. Good job!
ReplyDeleteIt was interesting how expanded on how the architecture of this structure is much different than other Islamic structures and that by focusing on this structure you were able to realize that there is not a specific way a structure from the Islamic world should look like. Great job!
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed reading through your analysis. The analysis was entertaining, interesting, and detailed. Nice Job!
ReplyDeleteWe enjoyed the analysis provided in the essay. Great job organizing your essay, it made it easier to follow along, and the simplicity of the blog post gave it a clean look to it that really made the images stand out amongst the page. Well done!
ReplyDeleteI really like the format of the blog, very easy to follow along. The analysis is very detailed, great job!
ReplyDeleteI like how you guys looked into the surrounding area to analyze the way this mosque attracts and influences people to approach it. Ir was interesting to read a different analysis perspective of this mosque.
ReplyDeleteI liked the attention to detail you guys wrote when describing the mosque!
ReplyDeleteVery interesting how no matter the size of a building, art and architecture prevail across many dimension and sizes. It is also nice to know (when you mentioned it) that this structure almost remains in the same similar state as it was constructed long ago. The way you analyzed the mosque's architectural elements and then described the Christian influences fits perfectly. Also, when I looked at the images from the "art detective section," the interior of the church you looked at in Huntington Park, CA reminds me of the Saints Peter and Paul Catholic Church's interior, located somewhat nearby in Wilmington, CA (also my current hometown). Perhaps catholic churches in "SoCal" actually have a common aesthetic and architectural design (considering California's former history with Spanish colonialism hundreds of years ago).
ReplyDeleteAs I was looking through your blog post , you can tell you were really detailed through it all. Like giving a good description on your images. Something I'll keep in consideration for the future!
ReplyDeleteInteresting connections between Islamic architecture and Catholic churches in California.
ReplyDeleteVery detailed and great formatting!
ReplyDeleteI liked the art detective section
DeleteReally liked how the information about the images was included. Simple and nice format website and was very easy to read with the double spaced. Interesting how different sized buildings show different dimensions. -Ibrahim Sabih
ReplyDeleteThe information about Figure 3 was very interesting for me that if one were to slide your hand through the stone of the building and arches it may leave scratches because the details are engraved.
ReplyDeleteThis was very interesting and I liked that you included details under the pictures.
ReplyDelete- Rosie Cabanas
Good straight forward analysis that's easy to follow and a sleek modern design! (Elle N.)
ReplyDeletei found your analysis very interesting and easy to follow, i also liked how you scattered the pictures it made it easier to follow along
ReplyDelete